Is Meursault Depressed?
Meursault’s
personality has been the topic of a lot of our discussions. He does not care
about anything and just seems to go along with whatever people tell him to do.
He also seems to like to do whatever is easiest for him and requires the least
amount of work. While I was reading the book I was wondering why Meursault did
not really care about anything. On the one hand, it could seem that the he is
suffering from depression and perhaps he used to have a different personality
when he was younger. However, he also seems pretty content with his life so
perhaps he simply does not care about anything and that is just part of who he
is.
Meursault
definitely shows signs that he could be depressed. He does not seem to care about
his future or about what is happening in his life, he does not even care about things
that could have a major impact on his him. For example, when his boss asks him
if he wants to move to Paris where he could have a better job and travel
Meursault just reacts by saying yes but he thinks that “it was all the same to
me [Meursault]” and he was not “dissatisfied (…) here at all” (41). His boss
has just given him a great job offer which is probably an upgrade from his old
job plus he gets to live in Paris. While most people would probably be excited
about an opportunity like that, Meursault does not care at all and he pretty
much just turns down the offer. When Marie asks Meursault to marry her, he says
that, “It didn’t make any difference to me and that we could if she wanted to”
(41). It seems that Meursault really likes Marie because he enjoys spending
time with her. However, he does seem to care about anything, especially when he
has to make a decision about something that could affect his future. His
non-caring attitude could be a sign that he is depressed. Meursault’s loss of
interest in activities and his constant tiredness could also be a sign that he
is depressed. Meursault sleeps a lot when he has nothing else to do and at both
his mother’s funeral and when he goes to Masson’s house he says that he is
feeling very tired. At one point Meursault decides to go out to the balcony and
he just sits there for hours with doing nothing except watching people go by.
However,
this does not necessarily mean that Meursault is depressed. It could also just
show that Meursault is a relaxed person who enjoys some time to himself just
watching the world go by. He also seems like a pretty happy person and he
enjoys many parts of his life. For example, he describes when he and Emmanuel are
chasing the truck and they are “hurtling forward in a mad dash through canes
and winches” and they are laughing and having a great time (26). Meursault
makes it seem like this is something they have done before so it is clear that he
definitely enjoys doing some activities and having fun. Meursault also brings
up how much he loves swimming and is clearly something that he really enjoys
doing. Meursault does care about some things and in some sense Meursault just
seems like a relaxed and happy guy. However, he has no interest in a lot of
other subjects and often just appears like he does not care about anything. Do
you think that he acts the way he does because he is depressed (or another
reason) or because he is a relaxed guy and that is just the way he is?
Meursault's apathy to Marie's inquiries about love struck me as a sign of depression, definitely. It's normal to not truly be into your quick fling, and to feel tired of them when they try to move into big emotions too quickly, but nonetheless the whole apathy in the face of passion thing is a trend I connote with a depressed brain.
ReplyDeleteI agree Meursault's behavior raises some red flags in terms of mental health. As I started reading the book, I too thought Meursault was depressed, or even worse, borderline suicidal. I think his intense apathy, especially towards his mother's death, was alarming.
ReplyDeleteThat being said though, I don't think Meursault is the same as any other human being. Although he believes the world has no intrinsic value, he still seems happy enough. He enjoys Marie's company, and as you pointed out, swimming. After reading the book, I'm more inclined to think Meursault has a unique nihilist philosophy, rather than him being purely depressed.
It's definitely an odd personality, but personally, I don't think he's really depressed. I think it's more that he just has a completely different world-view than anyone else, which can be interpreted and diagnosed in many ways by those around him, while for Meursault himself it's just how he interacts with the world, how he's always interacted with the world. The fact that it is such an alien perception on how people fit into the world makes it much harder for us to identify what the core principles of his world-view.
ReplyDelete